Home Blog Ask This Showcase Commentary Discussions About Us Contributors Contact Us
A little too much license for Homeland Security
ASK THIS | August 19, 2008

Marc Rotenberg writes that news reports on the government’s push to track vehicles by recording license plates have overlooked important issues, such as who the vendors will be, who will make sure the rules are being followed, and how the program will be evaluated.

By Marc Rotenberg
rotenberg@epic.org

In the past week, both the Washington Post and the New York Times have reported that the Department of Homeland Security has ambitious plans to track vehicles and record license plate numbers.

“Operation Sentinel” in New York, like the system planned for the nation's capital, will rely upon mobile and stationary hi-tech license plate readers to identify vehicles. Computer programs will then run the tags through databases, presumably to find matches to terrorist suspects -- but also to build more detailed profiles of Americans.

In typical fashion, privacy concerns are casually dismissed, while the underlying technology, the vendors involved, or even the rationale for the programs go unexplored beyond the recounting of some press-release anecdotes.

What’s needed is some serious reporting.

Q. What laws will limit the collection and use of this data? Federal agencies are showing little regard for federal and state privacy laws. What laws do the people backing this program plan to follow?

Q. Who are the vendors for the license plate project and what is their record? Vendors for many hi-tech projects are losing data at an alarming rate. Most recently Clear, the fast lane for airline travelers, lost information on 33,000 customers. A state Department contractor let its employees snoop through the passport records of the presidential candidates. What is the record of the companies that will collect license plate data?

Q. How will these systems be evaluated? Is there any hard data that shows that this is an effective public safety technique?

Q. What is the long-term plan? Already Homeland Security-funded surveillance cameras are being upgraded with new techniques that make possible actual identification in public spaces. What is next for the license plate reading devices -- weaponry to take out a vehicle suspected of carrying an IED?

Q. Extra credit: why won't the bad guys switch license plates or vehicles as they always have?

 Marc Rotenberg is Executive Director of the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) in Washington, D.C.
E-mail: rotenberg@epic.org
Comments
Submit a comment - Jump to bottom of list

Martin Lobel
It’s time to do more than just say the economy is the No. 1 issue
If voters are to go into the midterm elections with any understanding at all, the press needs to get away from he-said, she-said reporting and look into the positions that candidates and the two parties are taking. Martin Lobel offers some vital questions.

William Claiborne
What a broken Senate looks like from far away...and why it matters
Our correspondent in Australia has ideas on how to improve things a little. But he’s not optimistic that anyone on Capitol Hill will be interested.

Steven Greenhut
How severe is the public employee pension problem across the U.S.? (Hint: Is a $3 trillion debt severe?)
Columnist and author Steven Greenhut looks at the ongoing pension issue, including abuses of it, and deals with some of the key questions.

Watchdog Blog
Herb Strentz
 Des Moines Fair Coverage, Part 2
Cleaning up in the wake of the 2010 Iowa State Fair will be daunting this year. In addition to the mess left by nearly 1 million visitors and thousands of farm animals, we have a continuing saga of news coverage that told of possible racial assaults and then, in Saturday Night Live fashion, appears [...]

Herb Strentz
 On ‘Beat Whitey Night’ in Des Moines
(Editor’s note: The incidents described here have become part of a developing story, as this Google link shows.) The Des Moines Register’s reluctance to identify criminal suspects or victims by race has turned into an outright refusal to do so. The closing night of the Iowa State Fair was marked by an observance not exactly on the [...]

Barry Sussman
 Justice Department Shows Its Mettle, Indicts Clemens
I got this note from a friend and colleague a little while after Roger Clemens was indicted by a federal grand jury on Aug. 19th: “And meanwhile, Condoleezza Rice, Donald Rumsfeld, CIA officials and others who lied to Congress in sworn testimony about Iraq go free. If we can ‘look forward, not backward’ on torture, perjury, [...]

Blog main page >>
Web Essentials
Leading journalism sites, blogs...
Enter your e-mail address
Spotlight On

TWITTER
Follow Nieman Watchdog on Twitter.
(Nieman Watchdog)

Telecoms charging more to do nothing
It's getting more expensive to have an unlisted phone number. What's the logic behind that?
(Center for Media and Democracy)

Prosecute those leaks
The Obama administration has indicted another alleged leaker, this time for reportedly passing along to Fox News an intelligence assessment that North Korea was likely to respond to U.N. sanctions by conducting another nuclear test.
(Secrecy News/Federation of American Scientists)

A broad array of massive financial crimes
As PRWatch.org shows, court-imposed settlements have only skimmed the surface of big banks' wrongdoing in the financial crisis.
(Center for Media and Democracy)

More Spotlights >>
Site Policies  |  Nieman Foundation Home  |  Harvard University Home | XML RSS |
© 2010 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College