What happened to the 'coalition of the willing'?
ASK THIS
Cobbled together to deflect claims of U.S. unilateralism, the 'coalition' in Iraq left a lot be be desired to begin with, and it's now a mere shadow of what it once was.
By Neil Ripley nripley@niemanwatchdog.org
Back in March 2003, as the Bush administration was preparing for war without UN approval, President Bush touted a "coalition of the willing" to deflect claims of unilateral U.S. action. At that time, the White House reported that 49 countries, including the United States, were committed to the coalition.
The administration makes little mention of the coalition these days. Some say it never amounted to much to begin with, what with the absence of leading American allies and Muslim countries; other countries supplying very small numbers of soldiers; and those often in only a back-up role. But where does the coalition stand today?
At a May 9 hearing of a House Foreign Relations Committee panel, (the full transcript of which is now available on the House Web site) witnesses explained that the coalition is now about half of what it once was.
Joseph A. Christoff, director of international affairs and trade at the Government Accountability Office, said that as of May 2007, only 25 nations are in the coalition. Those nations are contributing 12,600 troops -- more than 7,000 coming from Great Britain. That’s compared to approximately 145,000 U.S. troops. Coalition forces have declined 47.5 percent from a December 2003 peak of 24,000, and currently account for just 8 percent of multinational forces in Iraq.
And Kenneth Katzman, a Middle East specialist with the Congressional Research Service, reported that “very few partner forces, coalition partners, are in the five most restive provinces: That is, Baghdad Province, Al Anbar, Salahuddin, Diyala, and Nineveh Province. The conclusion one could draw is that partner forces are not much of a factor on the actual battlefield per se, if one defines battlefield as combat primarily against Sunni insurgents. The bulk of actual combat is conducted by American forces, with the Iraqi security forces in a supporting role, and, I would argue, very much in the background on the combat.”
Katzman submitted the following chart:
Current State of US Coalition Forces
|
Country |
Troops |
Location |
Total Deaths
(2003-07) |
Status or Issues |
|
Albania |
120 |
Mosul,Nineveh province.
Multi-National Brigade North |
0 |
Increased troop level to 120 from 70 in 2005, remained fairly stable since that time. Seeking admittance to NATO in 2008. |
|
Armenia |
46 |
Al-Kut, Wasit province. Multinational Division (MND) Central- South |
0 |
No discussion of withdrawing troops. Serve under Polish command. Troops are non-combat. Approved to stay until end of 2007. |
|
Australia |
550 |
Tallil air base near Nassiryah in Dhi Qar province, southern Iraq.
MND South- East |
2 |
Prime Minister Howard staunch US supporter of Iraq War - no plans to withdraw despite growing pressure at home. Involved in training Iraqi forces. |
|
Azerbaijan |
150 |
Haditha, Anbar province.
MND West |
0 |
Protects hydroelectric power station. No plans reported to remove troops. |
|
Bosnia- Herzegovina |
36 |
MND North- Central |
0 |
Sent soldiers for a demining mission to Iraq in 2004, and Bosnian unit may be used to destroy improvised devices. Bosnia wants to cultivate image as a contributor to international security and hopes to join NATO. |
|
Bulgaria |
155
(120 non-combat; 35 support personnel) |
Ashraf Refugee Camp, north of Baghdad
MND Central- South |
13 |
In February 2007, voted to extend mission for another year. Bulgaria had withdrawn its light infantry battalion consisting of about 450 troops in 2005 after the deaths of 13 soldiers and 6 civilians and strong public discontent over the Iraqi war. |
|
Czech Republic |
99 |
Basra area
MND - South East |
0 |
Not considering withdrawing its troops as of February 2007 and will stay until at least the end of 2007. Training Iraqi policemen. Level of troops has remained relatively stable. |
|
Denmark |
460 |
Basra
MND South- East |
6 |
Announced that it will withdraw its troops in August 2007 and will send helicopter unit to replace ground troops. Prime Minister claims that the withdrawal decision illustrates progress made in southern Iraq. |
|
Estonia |
35 |
Baghdad |
2 |
No plans for withdrawal. Defends involvement as not an occupation of Iraq, but at the request of Iraq government. No significant change in troop levels since 2003. |
|
Fiji |
280 |
Baghdad
UN security force |
0 |
Troops serve in the UN guard unit protecting UN headquarters. Fiji became one of the coalition partners in 2003. |
|
Georgia |
850 elite troops
~ 50 other troops |
Baghdad - protecting Green Zone |
0 |
Georgia aspires to join NATO. Decision to increase troop levels to 2000 by June 2007 to protect border between Iraq and Iran and assist Baghdad security plan. |
|
Hungary |
150 |
Baghdad |
1 |
|
Kazakhstan |
27 |
MND Central- South |
1 |
No withdrawal plans. |
|
Latvia |
125 |
Diwaniya
MND Central- South |
3 |
Troops to be withdrawn by June 20. Will send additional troops to Afghanistan. |
|
Lithuania |
60 |
Basra
MND South- East |
0 |
Current troops deployed on six month mission which began February 2007. Polls show public support favoring withdrawal. |
|
Macedonia |
40 |
Taji
MND North- Central |
0 |
No withdrawal plans. Will keep troops in Iraq as long as US is there, according to statement May 1, 2007 by Chief of Staff Stojanovski. |
|
Moldova |
11 |
MND Central-South |
11 |
Troops returned home in January 2007. In April 2007, Parliament approved sending another 11 member team of bomb-diffusing experts to Iraq on a six month tour. |
|
Mongolia |
160 |
MND Central- South |
0 |
Part of Polish led sector. Current levels approved through July 2007. |
|
Netherlands |
15 |
Baghdad - NATO training mission |
2 |
According to Defense Minister Henk Kamp, contingent likely to stay until early 2009. |
|
Poland |
900 |
Diwaniya
MND Central- South |
20 |
Concentrates on reconstruction and security forces training. No plans to withdraw. In April 2007, President Kaczynski stated that Polish troops will not be driven out of Iraq and that mission may change as insurgent attacks have increased in southern areas of Iraq. |
|
Romania |
500 |
Southern Iraq under British command - mostly in Tallil and Basra
MND South-East |
2 |
Withdrew 99 troops from southern Iraq in April after UN mission in south ended. Prime Minister Tariceanu has called for withdrawal of remainder by end of 2007. Withdrawal must be approved by Supreme Defense Council chaired by Romanian President. President, however, has been suspended though on constitutional abuses (referendum to be held on May 19th). |
|
Slovakia |
6 |
Two in Baghdad - Four with Polish-led forces
MND Central- South |
4 |
In April 2007, withdrew five troops who were working with NATO forces training Iraqi military. No plans to withdraw remaining six servicemen. |
|
South Korea |
1,300 |
Irbil
MND North-Central |
0 |
Gradually drawing down. Reportedly will have timetable set up by July 2007 for withdrawal. |
|
United Kingdom |
7,100 |
Basra
MND South- East |
147 |
Reducing force level to 5,500 by end of summer. |
Source: CRS table created by Kim Walker Klarman. May 2, 2007.
Katzman also addressed the question of why the coalition has diminished. “Spain began a minor exodus in March 2004. There was a change of government there that did not agree with the original invasion,” he said. “Other governments left after the December 2005 elections in Iraq, claiming that political transition was complete. Others drew down after claiming that their areas were secure, and they were no longer needed. So there are different reasons in each case.”
Among the countries that have abandoned the coalition: Afghanistan; Angola; Colombia; Costa Rica; Dominican Republic; El Salvador, Eritrea; Ethiopia; Honduras; Hungary; Iceland; Italy; Japan; Kuwait; Marshall Islands; Micronesia; New Zealand; Nicaragua; Norway; Palau; Panama; Philippines; Portugal; Rwanda; Singapore; Solomon Islands; Spain; Thailand; Tonga; Turkey; Uganda; Ukraine; Uzbekistan.
Posted by
Michael Haynes -
06/25/2007, 09:52 AM
And how much money are we bribing these countrys with untold Billions in forign aid to be part of the coalition ?
|
|
Bruce Kushnick questions whether AT&T and Verizon are trying to kill off the “plain old telephone service” that millions of Americans rely on. In a recent FCC filing cited by Kushnick, AT&T stated that landline utilities are from a bygone era, and asked to be relieved of its obligations to service them. 
The GAO showed that contractors’ estimates have nothing to do with reality, and economic hard times may eventually force the President and Congress to rein in outrageously costly warships, planes and missile systems that don’t work. But that time isn’t here yet. 
It’s easy to find activism, impossible to find original intent behind the Roberts/Scalia group’s ruling on corporate political spending. Martin Lobel suggests six sharp, practical steps to deal with it. 
|

As an old assignment editor I’m used to asking questions and not being embarrassed if they expose me as naïve or wrong minded, because sometimes there’s a good story lurking. So here are a few simple questions. The biggest financial institutions are said to be on the verge of issuing $145 billion in bonuses. My [...] 
A friend and contributor to Nieman Watchdog, Martin Lobel, sent this emaiI with the suggestion that people pass it along. Looks worth passing along to me. Here’s Marty:
“I don’t know whether you’re as upset with the Supreme Court’s legislating in Citizens United v. FEC as I am, but there is a simple solution that is [...] 
Item: The New York Times reported Friday afternoon that “two more Democratic senators” said they would vote against a second term for Fed Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke. From there, the Times said this made it unclear “whether there were the 60 votes necessary to confirm Mr. Bernanke.”
Excuse me? Sixty votes are not necessary to [...] 
Blog main page >>
|
Leading journalism sites, blogs...  |
|
|

|
TWITTER
Follow Nieman Watchdog on Twitter.
(Nieman Watchdog)
Torture probe abandoned
For lack of interest, the Senate will not move ahead on the idea to appoint a commission to investigate detention, rendition and interrogation policies by the U.S. during the George W. Bush administration.
(Secrecy News)
Find John Brennan's op ed
Harry Shearer, working from a fantasy assignment desk, wants reporters to find a 2005 anti-Iraq war op ed that never was published.
(Huffington Post)
Those Mohammed cartoons
On Jan 2 a man with an axe tried to attack the Danish artist whose 12 depictions of the prophet Mohammed created a furor in 2005. After the failed attack, a Norwegian newspaper reprinted six of the drawings.
(Editors Weblog)
Afghanistan surge to rely heavily on private contractors
Private contractors are expected to make up at least half of the total military workforce in Afghanistan, according to Defense Department officials cited in a recent study from the Congressional Research Service. The number of contractors will likely increase by between 16,000 and 56,000 for a total of 120,000-160,000.
(TPM Muckraker)
Recession scars will be lasting
The aftershocks from deep recessions reverberate for years, even decades.
(USA Today)
The curious spending of a GOP pro-choice PAC
The money doesn't seem to actually go to supporting choice.
(Center for Public Integrity)
More Spotlights >>
|
|